   
|
Rubric
Focus
The
focus
of the rubric is based on the subject that is to be assessed and the breadth
of the subject matter the rubric is to assess. Care should be taken
to select a focus that is clear to others as well as to yourself exactly
what the rubric will measure. A rubric can be either holistic,
globally measuring a single trait, or analytic,
breaking down a complex concept into constituent parts.
Consider
a rubric that is supposed to identify how well any of the students in band
played an assigned section of a piece the band was working on. This
rubric would be holistic
and it would be generic.
That is, there is to be one scale that measures the totality of each student's
playing no matter if the student plays flute, clarinet, saxophone, oboe,
trumpet, trombone, or percussion.
A good
method for assuring that the rubric being developed stays "on-track" or
remains focused on its original intent is to clearly write the focus at
the top of the page on which the rubric is being developed. For the
generic
rubric described in the preceding paragraph, the following might be appropriate.
This
generic rubric will determine the overall performance level of band students
in playing a section of practiced band music.
Any musical
performance can be broken down into many different aspects that have the
potential to be assessed. For instance, the intonation, technical
facility, rhythm, and musicality are other parts of a musical performance
that could be assessed. One approach would be to develop a multiple
analytic
rubrics to provide students with information about how well they are performing
on each of these musically meaningful dimensions. Such a set of multiple
rubrics might have the following description.
This
generic rubric will determine the overall performance level of band students
in playing a section of practiced band music.

Copyright © 1999
All Rights Reserved
Edward P. Asmus, Ph.D.
|
|